Respond To A Proposed VA Rating Reduction

Identify Exactly What VA Proposes To Change

Read the heading and action described in the notice before choosing a response. A proposal to lower a disability evaluation is different from a final reduction decision. Severing service connection is different again: it removes the recognized connection to service rather than simply changing the percentage. A dependency adjustment or temporary-rating expiration may follow different rules.

Make a short record of the affected disability, current and proposed percentages, notice date, stated reason, and whether the monthly payment would change. Save every page and the envelope or electronic notice. Get accredited help promptly if the letter is unclear; a claim-status label does not replace the notice itself.

Sources: 38 CFR 3.105: Proposed Reductions And Predetermination Hearings · Get Help From An Accredited Representative

Calendar The Qualified Response Periods

When section 3.105(e) applies because a proposed lower evaluation would reduce or stop compensation currently being paid, VA must explain the proposal and allow 60 days to submit evidence supporting continuation. A predetermination-hearing request must reach VA within 30 days of the notice. A timely hearing request generally continues the existing payment pending the final determination under these procedures.

These are different deadlines for different actions. Request the hearing explicitly if you want one, using the notice’s instructions; do not assume submitting medical records requests a hearing. If the overall payment would not decrease, do not assume the same proposal procedure applies. Keep submission confirmation and verify receipt before the deadline.

Sources: 38 CFR 3.105: Proposed Reductions And Predetermination Hearings

Address The Alleged Improvement With Specific Evidence

Compare the examination or records VA relies on with the earlier evidence supporting the rating. Identify exactly what VA says improved. Then gather current records and truthful examples showing whether that change is sustained in ordinary life. A statement that you disagree is less informative than identifying an omitted flare pattern, a misunderstood limitation, or a temporary improvement during unusually restricted activity.

For stabilized ratings covered by section 3.344, VA must consider the history and whether examinations are sufficiently complete. Certain conditions with episodic improvement cannot generally be reduced on one examination unless all the evidence demonstrates sustained improvement. Explain the factual issue with supporting records; do not assume every shorter examination is legally inadequate.

• Compare the old and new findings for the same functions and symptoms.
• Identify relevant treatment or testing that the proposal appears to omit.
• Ask a treating clinician to explain any temporary change or inconsistent findings.

Sources: 38 CFR 3.344: Stabilized Disability Evaluations

Check Five-, Ten-, And Twenty-Year Protections Separately

These time periods protect different things. Ratings maintained at the same level for five years or more may receive the stabilization protections in section 3.344. That is not an absolute ban on reduction. Service connection in effect for ten years generally has protection from severance, with exceptions including fraud or lack of qualifying service or discharge status; it does not freeze the percentage.

A disability continuously rated at or above a level for twenty years generally cannot be reduced below that protected level except for fraud. Calculate the relevant period using the effective dates specified by the rule, not simply the date printed on the latest letter. A recent increase does not necessarily make the entire older rating history irrelevant.

Sources: 38 CFR 3.344: Stabilized Disability Evaluations · 38 CFR 3.957: Protection Of Service Connection · 38 CFR 3.951: Preservation Of Disability Ratings

Check Additional Rules For Total Ratings

Total disability ratings have additional provisions under section 3.343. For covered schedular total ratings, VA generally needs an examination showing material improvement considered with the whole record and ordinary conditions of life. Temporary ratings based on treatment are not governed identically. A 100% label alone does not tell you which protection applies.

TDIU reductions have separate requirements concerning actual employability. The regulation also limits reduction based solely on beginning substantially gainful work unless the occupation is maintained for twelve consecutive months. That is not a blanket permission to ignore employment-reporting requests or a promise that every work situation is protected. Bring the employment history and any VA verification notice to your representative.

Sources: 38 CFR 3.343: Continuance Of Total Disability Ratings

Treat A Final Decision As A New Procedural Step

After the proposal process, read any final decision for the reduction date, reasons, evidence considered, and review instructions. For reductions governed by section 3.105(e), the regulation generally places the reduction after the specified 60-day period following final notice, at the month-end boundary. Do not calculate that date from the proposal alone.

A final decision may require a formal review request even if you disputed the proposal. Ordinary Higher-Level Review and Board Appeal requests generally have a one-year deadline from the decision notice; follow the instructions for your particular decision. Match the option to the evidence, and ask about restoration and the reduction’s effective date. An intent to file or telephone inquiry does not replace a required review request or extend its deadline.

Sources: 38 CFR 3.105: Proposed Reductions And Predetermination Hearings · VA Decision Reviews And Appeals · Choosing A Decision Review Option · Higher-Level Review Requirements And Deadline · Board Appeal Requirements And Deadline · Your Intent To File A VA Claim

Common Questions